By Abul Baraa Muhammad Amreekii.
Introduction
The history of Islam in Black America is a story of resilience, transformation, and the search for dignity in the face of oppression. At the heart of this history lies the figure of the Imam, the spiritual and communal leader tasked with guiding Muslims toward moral integrity, religious devotion, and collective empowerment. For Black Muslims, this role was charged with even greater weight, as the Imam stood at the intersection of faith, identity, and survival in a hostile society.
Yet, when we examine this history critically, we are forced to confront a sobering reality: many of the Imams who claimed the mantle of Black Conscience failed their Muslim communities. Rather than nurturing and defending the believers entrusted to them, too many abandoned their responsibilities, compromised their principles, or reduced leadership to ritual without vision.
The Role of the Imam in the Muslim Community
Traditionally, the Imam is expected to serve not only as a prayer leader but as a shepherd of the faithful — a teacher, counselor, and protector of the community. Within the Black Muslim context, this role carried an added dimension: to cultivate a uniquely Black Muslim identity that preserved dignity in the face of racism, while grounding believers firmly in Islamic principles.
This meant teaching Islam with clarity, providing moral guidance, defending the vulnerable, and building institutions that could sustain the community. It meant modeling piety while also embodying courage. Above all, it required a deep accountability to the Muslim community itself, for the Imam’s first responsibility is to those who stand behind him in prayer.
The Failures of Leadership
Despite these expectations, many Black Conscience Imams faltered. Their failures manifested in several ways:
Neglect of Spiritual Guidance – Instead of nurturing the faith of their congregants, some reduced Islam to outward rituals or empty slogans. Sermons often repeated clichés rather than addressing the real spiritual and social struggles Muslims faced. Many failed to guide youth struggling with faith, identity, or systemic pressures, leaving them vulnerable to disillusionment.
Authoritarian Leadership – Some Imams treated their role as a position of power rather than service. Instead of consultation and shared responsibility (shura), they demanded blind obedience. This created environments of control, fear, and stagnation, where the growth of the community was stifled.
Worldly Compromises – Too many sought legitimacy through political connections, state approval, or financial gain. In doing so, they silenced themselves on injustices affecting their own Muslim congregations — from surveillance and profiling to economic marginalization. The prophetic voice of Islam was muted in exchange for institutional comfort.
Moral Failures – Some betrayed the very ethical standards they preached, through corruption, exploitation, or personal misconduct. These failures not only damaged individual communities but also discredited Islam in the eyes of many who were seeking authentic spiritual leadership.
Failure to Build for the Future – Instead of cultivating young leaders, many Imams kept authority tightly in their own hands. When they passed away or were discredited, communities collapsed because no strong, educated, principled leadership had been nurtured to carry the torch forward.
Consequences for the Muslim Community
The failure of these Imams had devastating consequences. Instead of being sanctuaries of faith and guidance, many mosques became irrelevant to the daily lives of Black Muslims. Members drifted away, disillusioned by hypocrisy or neglect. Youth turned elsewhere for meaning — sometimes toward destructive alternatives, sometimes toward other movements that seemed more alive to their struggles.
Worse still, the gap left by weak or compromised leadership meant that Islam’s transformative potential within the Black community was stunted. Where the mosque should have been a fortress of faith, family, and resistance, it too often stood silent or empty.
The Missed Prophetic Example
Islamic history offers countless examples of leaders who embodied sincerity, courage, and sacrifice. The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) described leadership as a responsibility, not a privilege. The Imam was to be the first servant of his people, accountable before God for how he guided the flock.
By failing to uphold this standard, many Black Conscience Imams betrayed the very essence of their role. Instead of protecting their communities, they often exposed them to disunity, stagnation, or decline. Their failure was not only institutional but spiritual: a neglect of the sacred trust of amana (trust) that comes with leading believers.
Toward Renewal and Accountability
Criticism, however, is not hopelessness. If the history of failure teaches us anything, it is that the Muslim community cannot afford to entrust its future blindly to leaders without accountability. Renewal begins with demanding integrity, knowledge, and service from Imams. It requires training leaders who are rooted in the Qur’an and Sunnah, but also deeply aware of the social realities facing Black Muslims in America.
It also requires communities themselves to awaken. The Black Conscience must not remain in the hands of leaders alone; it must be a shared project of faith and justice. Only then can mosques return to their prophetic role as centers of guidance, dignity, and transformation.
My Final Thoughts
The condition of the African American Muslim community must be examined critically if we are to understand the crisis of leadership that defines our present moment. This essay continues the discussion on the failure of the so-called “Black conscience Imams,” those men who occupy positions of religious authority in the African American Muslim community but who, despite their training, education, and resources, have failed to meet the urgent needs of their people. The matter is not small, nor is it confined to theological disputes; it strikes at the heart of what leadership in Islam is meant to be, and how leadership has historically manifested in the lives of oppressed peoples.
In the past, leadership within the African American Muslim community had a different character. Figures such as Malcolm X, though not formally trained in the Islamic sciences, were recognized as leaders not only among Muslims but among the wider Black community. Malcolm X was visible, courageous, and uncompromising in his commitment to justice. He named the systems of oppression plainly and without hesitation, whether that oppression was racial, political, or economic. His speeches transcended the walls of the mosque and reached into the broader struggles of African Americans in the United States. Similarly, Warith Deen Muhammad, though different in theology and orientation, represented a leader whose name and presence were widely recognized. Even the Nation of Islam, with its theological shortcomings, produced figures who commanded respect and visibility.
These men were leaders because they connected directly to the condition of the people. They were not isolated figures known only within their mosques; they were national voices, household names, and symbols of resistance. The fact that an elderly Christian woman—my own mother—knows Malcolm X and Warith Deen Muhammad testifies to the degree to which these leaders transcended the boundaries of religious community. They were known because they stood at the intersection of faith and social struggle. Their leadership, while imperfect, embodied a principle that lies at the very heart of Islam: to speak truth to power and to defend the oppressed.
By contrast, the contemporary African American Muslim leadership has largely withdrawn from this model. Today, there exists a cohort of imams and students of knowledge who have studied extensively in Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and other centers of Islamic learning. They possess credentials, fluency in Arabic, and mastery of the religious sciences that earlier leaders never had. On paper, they should be more prepared than Malcolm X ever was to lead the Muslim community. And yet, in practice, they are almost entirely absent from the pressing struggles of African Americans.
The contemporary imam, for all his knowledge, has limited himself to ritual instruction. He is found teaching prayer, fasting, Qur’anic recitation, and the rules of purification. While these are important and necessary elements of Islam, the religion has never been confined to ritual. From its very inception, Islam was a movement that transformed societies, liberated the oppressed, and confronted injustice. To reduce it to ritual alone is to hollow out its revolutionary spirit. The imams who restrict themselves in this way, intentionally or not, perpetuate the silencing of Islam’s liberating power in the African American context.
Islam has never been a religion divorced from social justice. When Muslims entered Egypt, they did so not as mere conquerors but as liberators of a population long oppressed by Roman rule. Heavy taxation and social marginalization under the Byzantine regime had crushed ordinary Egyptians, and the arrival of Islam alleviated those burdens. Similarly, when Muslims entered Spain, they brought relief to populations who had been living under oppressive rulers. These moments in history remind us that Islam has always aligned itself with the oppressed, with those who bore the weight of unjust systems. The Qur’an commands Muslims to stand firmly for justice, even against themselves, their kin, or the powerful of society.
If Islam could be a force of liberation for the Egyptians against the Romans, if it could relieve oppressed peoples in Spain, then how is it possible that Islam in America today has been reduced by its leaders to private rituals and academic lectures? How is it that the very imams who have been trained in the traditions of justice and liberation are silent in the face of mass incarceration, police brutality, systemic racism, generational poverty, and educational neglect? Their silence is not merely a personal shortcoming. It is a betrayal of both their people and their faith.
The prophetic mission was never confined to worship alone. The Prophet Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him, was a leader who confronted the injustices of Meccan society, challenged the exploitation of the weak, and built a community based on justice and equity. He did not teach prayer rituals while ignoring oppression; he brought a religion that integrated ritual devotion with social transformation. To separate these is to misrepresent the religion itself.
This is precisely where the Black conscience Imams of today have failed. They have allowed themselves to be silenced, whether by fear, by misplaced priorities, or by the comfort of isolation. They have chosen safety over struggle, ritual over justice, and invisibility over leadership. As a result, the African American Muslim community remains without leaders who can stand alongside Malcolm X in the annals of history. We have knowledge, but no courage. We have credentials, but no presence. We have imams, but no leaders.
Until this crisis is addressed, the African American Muslim community will remain weak and disconnected from the very tradition that once inspired oppressed peoples across the world. Leadership must return to its prophetic roots. Imams must rediscover their obligation to defend the oppressed, to speak truth to power, and to embody Islam not only in ritual but in the lived reality of justice. Only then will we see the revival of a leadership worthy of our people and worthy of our faith.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the tragedy of the Black Conscience Imams is not simply that they failed as individuals, but that their failure left generations of Muslims without the guidance and protection they desperately needed. By neglecting their trust, compromising their principles, and prioritizing themselves over their people, they weakened the very communities they were meant to uplift.
Yet, in recognizing this failure, there lies an opportunity. The call today is for a new generation of leadership — accountable, principled, and rooted in faith. For the Black Muslim community to thrive, it must no longer tolerate complacency or corruption. Instead, it must insist upon leaders who live by conscience, uphold justice, and serve their people with humility and courage.
More works of Abul Baraa Muhammad Amreeki:
Works of Abul Baraa Muhamad Amreeki 
Leave a comment